Media contact: Trisha Morales, [email protected]
“Don’t Tell People About the Worst-Case Scenario”: TCEQ’s Advice to Industry Raises Alarms
Air Alliance Houston questions state regulator’s recent guidance to industry representatives and calls for transparency and accountability
HOUSTON, TX — Air Alliance Houston (AAH) is raising concerns about comments made by the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality (TCEQ) to industry representatives at a recent statewide permitting workshop on how to fast-track their air permits and obfuscate community concerns.
During the Octubre 6 Advanced Air Permitting Seminar at the UT Commons Conference Center in Austin (and online), TCEQ officials offered industry representatives tips about navigating the permit approval process faster and how to engage with community members.
Of particular concern to AAH was advice offered during a presentation on public participation, where TCEQ leadership advised industry representatives: “Don’t tell people about the worst-case scenario that could happen if something catastrophic happens at your plant and how it would be a bad thing for everybody.” Instead, the presenter suggested highlighting positive interactions with the community.
For communities living near industrial plants, concrete batch facilities, and other sources of air pollution, AAH believes this guidance raises important questions about whether residents have access to the information they need to participate meaningfully in decisions affecting their neighborhoods.
“The state’s environmental regulator should be helping residents understand pollution risks and inviting meaningful stakeholder engagement, not simply training industry on how to placate public concerns,” said Dawson Phillips of Air Alliance Houston, who attended the workshop. “Communities deserve transparent information and a meaningful opportunity to participate in decisions that affect their lives.”
TCEQ Views Public Participation as Irrelevant to Their Decisions
During discussions about public engagement, TCEQ presenters offered guidance on navigating public meetings and responding to community feedback. One presenter distinguished between comments considered “relevant” to permit decisions and those expressing “general opposition” to a proposed facility. They later suggested that a higher number of public meeting requests in densely populated areas, such as Houston, does not necessarily indicate significant public interest.
Says Phillips, “TCEQ’s decision to consider public meeting requests in urban areas as less significant systematically devalues the voices of frontline communities in cities like Houston, where communities are often exposed to multiple neighborhood-level sources of air pollution located in close proximity to dense residential areas.”
TCEQ Celebrates Avoiding Penalties and Permitting Requirements
During the seminar, TCEQ officials discussed their efforts to seek regulatory relief for industry by demonstrating that air pollution originating outside Texas and even the U.S. contributes to violations of federal air quality standards in local places like Houston.
Presenters emphasized the potential benefits of these efforts to industry, including helping them avoid penalties and stricter permitting requirements in areas that fail to meet federal air quality standards.
Says Phillips, “During the seminar, TCEQ acknowledged that agency air quality data shows that communities across Texas are breathing unhealthy levels of air pollution. However, rather than strengthening clean air regulations to protect public health, TCEQ has instead prioritized reducing its own regulatory obligation and defending polluters’ right to pollute. They are even celebrating this.”
The Need for Accountability and Transparency is More Important Than Ever
“We have long suspected that TCEQ does not respect the input of community members, and the messages from their staff at this workshop, in their own words, is further proof,” says Jennifer Hadayia, executive director of Air Alliance Houston. “Houstonians are not perils to be navigated on the fast track to an air permit. We demand change.”
AAH is calling on TCEQ to explain how its training programs balance the interests of regulated industries with its responsibility to protect public health and the environment and to ensure the state’s public participation laws are implemented meaningfully.
AAH is urging the agency to clarify how residents’ concerns are considered during permit decisions and to ensure that community members have access to the information, guidance, and resources necessary to participate effectively in the permitting process.
The organization believes that transparency and equitable public participation are essential to building public trust and ensuring that environmental permitting decisions adequately consider the health and well-being of Texas communities.
AAH has recordings of the workshop, and the presentation materials are available on the TCEQ’s own website. AAH is making its recordings and other materials from the workshop available to journalists.
###
Air Alliance Houston is a nonprofit environmental justice organization working to reduce the public health impacts of air pollution and advance environmental justice through research, education, and advocacy.